Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
The Shoe Fairy

Olympian Mule

Regular price $84.99
True to size / Semi-wide width

Scared to rock a mule? Worried your foot will slide right out and it won't feel secure?

You're not alone! We realized this was a common problem so we created the solution! Our Olympian Mule has extended (comfortable) plastic coverage to ensure your foot feels secure. This strapless look is bound to elongate your legs for a sleek, fabulous look!

Features:  5" heel and 3/4" platform, synthetic sparkly insole (Vegan-Friendly), flexible/soft plastic upper, cushioned insole for amazing comfort, rounded footbed, vegan heels, gray bottoms for an ultra sleek finish

Sizing: Medium width, true to size. If you are a half size, we suggest sizing DOWN to the nearest whole size. These run more on the "big" side.

If your foot is wider or the plastic feels tight, you may apply heat from a blow dryer for 10-30 seconds to help the plastic expand and stretch. 

Narrow Feet? Check out our custom insert here.

Maintenance: Easy to clean insole! This insole can be wiped clean in just 60 seconds with some warm water and soap. It dries instantly and will look brand new.   



Yes, we accept returns! You may return your items for store credit or a refund within 30 days of your original order. Read the full Policy HERE.


These heels do NOT come in wide styles! However, we do have a few styles that have a wider toe bed. These include Olympian, Lush, Luminous, Bella, Nova Bella and Knockout.


Priority U.S Shipping: 2-3 business days
Express U.S Shipping: 1-2 business days

*Shipping times do NOT include handling time. Orders placed Monday – Thursday are typically shipped within 24hrs or less. Orders placed Friday morning will be shipped on Friday. Orders placed Friday afternoon/evening, Saturday and Sunday will be shipped on Monday.

For international information, click HERE.

We hope the shoe fits! If not, we have hassle-free Returns. You may return your items for store credit or a refund within 30 days of your original order. 

Read the FULL Policy HERE for complete details.


why we made this
The Olympian line was created by a competitor, FOR competitors! This is NOT another heel mass produced for profit, it's a heel that was carefully crafted for you. The soft/flexible plastic and cushioned insole provides you with the comfort that you deserve. The rounded foot bed, transparent platform and gray bottoms create a flawless look that you can't find anywhere else. One of our favorite parts is the insole! Not only does it sparkle, but it is very easy to clean. No more dirty spray tanned insoles! The Olympian Mule was created to solve the common problem of women feeling scared to rock a strapless heel! The current heels on the market just didn't seem to feel secure enough. We made the foot strap have extended coverage to feel more secure so YOU feel more confident! #PinkBoxSquad #GrayBottoms

Customer Reviews

Based on 92 reviews
Laurel Beeman
Most comfortable competition heel.

I took a leap and ordered the mule and I can’t believe it’s so comfortable and easy to wear! I’m so happy that I took my posing coach’s advice and went with The Shoe Fairy!

Alicia Hammer
Best Decision I've made!

The Olympian Mule is by far one of the best shoes offered by The Shoe Fairy. I have a pair of the Olympians with the ankle straps that I absolutely love, but I noticed that I was having trouble getting them on at times when it was time to get on stage and trying to strap them on with fake nails wasn't my best idea. The mules slip on so easy and offer the same elegance and comfort and I absolutely love them! I was worried about getting them at first because I totally thought I would accidentally kick them off into the judges face without the straps but they are snug enough to stay on your foot and comfortable enough to hit all your poses perfectly! I would recommend them to anyone looking for an awesome heel that offers ease of a slip on, comfort, and elegance!

Cheryl Lambert
Great fit, Super comfortable!!!!

Beautiful shoes, very well balanced and a great fit. Bonus they are extremely comfortable!!!

Marnie R.
Didn’t need to size down

I usually fit a 6.5 or 7 and chose to size down as it said this shoe runs large. This was not my experience at all. I found the 6 to be very short. Therefore I have returned them for the 7.
I will say they came promptly, were packaged beautifully and I can’t wait to get my larger size!

Size Up

My first impression when I tired the Olympian Mule was, ok. Nothing special about them really. The sole is a lot better than other heels. They do feel comfortable. After reading the description about sizing down I decided to go with a size 9 since I am a 9.5. I should have sized up to a 10 instead. The only reason why I won't be returning these is because they charge you for it which I feel is unfair in a way since I took the advice of the author about sizing down. 🤷‍♀️ is it worth the money? Not really. The only thing I liked about these was the sole.

People who bought this product, also bought