Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
The Shoe Fairy

Heel Good Insert

Regular price $9.99 Free Instant Exchanges

The Shoe Fairy's exclusive insert is here! Designed to fit perfectly in our Olympian Heels. We searched high and low for an insert to solve a common problem: feet sliding forward in high heels. 

Turns out, we just could not find what we wanted! So, we created our very own. We received insight from a podiatrist and went to work!

  • Sold as a pair.
  • Made of a high-quality, dense foam material that will not flatten over time.
  • Not a one size fits all product. We want this insert to fit YOUR foot perfectly. Which is why there are 3 different sizes to ensure you get the right fit. 
  • Prevents feet from sliding forward in heel. 
  • Adds a substantial amount of comfort for the balls of your feet. We're talking, WALKING ON CLOUDS, type of feeling!
  • Self adhesive, removable. We recommend keeping them in your shoe and not removing them to keep the adhesive strong. 
  • Reduces extra space in the shoe for those who have narrow feet and want a tighter fit. 

Please note, since this cushion is very dense, it is only applicable if you have some extra space. If you have a wide foot and no extra space within the shoe, we do not recommend adding any inserts. 


Yes! Items may be exchanged or returned within 30 days of your order. All items MUST be in original condition to be eligible for a return. Read the full Policy HERE.


These heels do NOT come in wide styles! However, we do have a few styles that have a wider toe bed. These include Olympian, Lush, Luminous, Bella, Nova Bella and Knockout.


Priority U.S Shipping: 2-3 business days
Express U.S Shipping: 1-2 business days

*Shipping times do NOT include handling time. Orders placed Monday – Thursday are typically shipped within 24hrs or less. Orders placed Friday morning will be shipped on Friday. Orders placed Friday afternoon/evening, Saturday and Sunday will be shipped on Monday.

For international information, click HERE.

We hope the shoe fits! If not, we have hassle-free Returns & FREE INSTANT EXCHANGES! Items may be exchanged or returned within 30 days of your order. All items MUST be in original condition to be eligible for a return.

Read the FULL Policy HERE for complete details.


why we made this
Okay, real talk here from woman to woman. When I competed in 2015, my toes slid over the front of the heels and hung off (looking horrible). It drove me nuts! The common solution is to put an insert in the ball of foot area of your heels. The downfall to most of them on the market was that they flatten out quickly and end up not preventing the toe over hang. When I created my Olympian line, I wanted a solution to this problem. I also wanted a solution for the ladies with narrow feet who struggle with heels being too loose AND the common problem of the plastic stretching too much. Thus, the Heel Good Insert was born. After testing every insert on the market, I decided to create my own. Made of SUPER dense material that won't flatten out so that it actually DOES it's job! #ForWomenByWomen

Customer Reviews

Based on 59 reviews
Guillermo Pina
Very thick and comfortable

I loved that it is very thick and comfortable but my foot still goes a bit towards the front that’s why I’d give it 3 stars. Must say though, best I’ve tried on the market


Heel Good Insert

Tonya Bauchman

It helped fit more snug

Kari Mccluey
Heel Good Inserts, totally rad!

Heel Good inserts are the bomb! Who'd have thought these little things would make such a huge difference? So glad I tried them, they are awesome!

Julie Noone
Huge difference!

I got the insert because my toes were sliding forward in my heels. They made all the difference!

People who bought this product, also bought