Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert
Heel Good Insert

Heel Good Insert

Regular price $9.99

The Shoe Fairy's exclusive insert is here! Designed to fit perfectly in our Olympian Heels. We searched high and low for an insert to solve a common problem: feet sliding forward in high heels. 

Turns out, we just could not find what we wanted! So, we created our very own. We received insight from a podiatrist and went to work!

  • Made of a high-quality, dense foam material that will not flatten over time.
  • Not a one size fits all product. We want this insert to fit YOUR foot perfectly. Which is why there are 3 different sizes to ensure you get the right fit. 
  • Prevents feet from sliding forward in heel. 
  • Adds a substantial amount of comfort for the balls of your feet. We're talking, WALKING ON CLOUDS, type of feeling!
  • Self adhesive, removable. We recommend keeping them in your shoe and not removing them to keep the adhesive strong. 
  • Reduces extra space in the shoe for those who have narrow feet and want a tighter fit. 

Please note, since this cushion is very dense, it is only applicable if you have some extra space. If you have a wide foot and no extra space within the shoe, we do not recommend adding any inserts. 


Yes, we accept returns! You may return your items for store credit or a refund within 30 days of your original order. Read the full Policy HERE.


These heels do NOT come in wide styles! However, we do have a few styles that have a wider toe bed. These include Olympian, Lush, Luminous, Bella, Nova Bella and Knockout.


Priority U.S Shipping: 2-3 business days
Express U.S Shipping: 1-2 business days

*Shipping times do NOT include handling time. Orders placed Monday – Thursday are typically shipped within 24hrs or less. Orders placed Friday morning will be shipped on Friday. Orders placed Friday afternoon/evening, Saturday and Sunday will be shipped on Monday.

For international information, click HERE.

We hope the shoe fits! If not, we have hassle-free Returns. You may return your items for store credit or a refund within 30 days of your original order. 

Orders with Clear Heels will come with a prepaid return label. 

Read the full Policy HERE.


Why choose us?
Women Empowering Women

We are women owned and operated! The Shoe Fairy was founded in 2015 by a fellow competitor! Alexa noticed there was no one known for stage heels and that’s how the idea of the Shoe Fairy was born. This was and is still a dream. A dream that is becoming reality. That’s what sets us apart from other companies. This is not just a business. This is a PASSION that blood, sweat, tears and heart has been poured into. When you shop with the Shoe Fairy, you are supporting people that will support and love you right back. 

We're Here to Help

Let's connect! Customer Service is our number 1 priority. No question is silly to us! We are here to make your shopping experience be the best it can be. Our products are our specialty and we love to answer your questions! When you shop with the Shoe Fairy you are just a click away from getting in contact directly with our team for one on one support.

Customer Reviews

Based on 7 reviews
Imperfections Olympian Heels

It’s the most comfortable heels I’ve worn and the imperfections it had were so minuscule I could not tell by first looks unless you’re really start looking. Overall to me they are perfect.


These definitely add some nice, comfy squish to your heels! However, they also take away space so I'd only recommend them if your heels fit a little on the loose/bigger side.

Heel good insert

My foot still moves forward a little bit, but much better than not having them in


I have had two pervious pairs of fabulicious brand clear PVC heels for NPC competition which I liked. They fit fine, were reasonably comfortable and a good price. I purchased the Olympia from The Shoe Fairy to see if they lived up to the hype - AND ALL I CAN SAY IS THEY DO! They have a bit more coverage over the toes/top of the foot so putting them on can feel like the toes are squished at first but stand in them for a minute or two and let the plastic warm up and there is no trouble!!! They relax and keep toes in place unlike many other posing shoes where feet begin to slide through and toes can end up peeking off the end of the shoe!!! The footbed is cushioned and oh so comfy!! I’m an ankle strap gal and really like them so these are perfect for me. I hope TSF makes a version with a rhinestoned platform/heel and a version without an ankle strap for all my gals who prefer a slip on mule!! Sizing was TTS and consistent with typical PVC heels.Fast shipping! I would highly recommend and will personally purchase again! Thx TSF 😘🥰❤️

Heavenly Heels

I cannot begin to share my excitement to wear these heals this year at competition. They are beyond comfortable for a woman at the young age of 58 soon to be 59🤗💪💝.

People who bought this product, also bought