4.7 (118 reviews)

Heel Good Insert

$15AUD

The Shoe Fairy's exclusive ball of foot insert, designed to keep your feet secure, supported, and comfortable in every step. Made with premium dense foam and podiatrist insight, it helps prevent your feet from sliding forward while adding plush cushioning exactly where you need it most.

Size: 5/6/7

In Stock

Est. U.S. DeliveryGET IT BEFORE OCT. 14

Worldwide Shippingshown at checkout

Return & exchangewithin 30 days

Product Details

The Shoe Fairy's exclusive insert is here! Designed to fit perfectly in our Olympian Heels. We searched high and low for an insert to solve a common problem: feet sliding forward in high heels.

Turns out, we just could not find what we wanted! So, we created our very own. We received insight from a podiatrist and went to work!

Sold as a pair.
Made of a high-quality, dense foam material that will not flatten over time.
Not a one size fits all product. We want this insert to fit YOUR foot perfectly. Which is why there are 3 different sizes to ensure you get the right fit.
Prevents feet from sliding forward in heel.
Adds a substantial amount of comfort for the balls of your feet. We're talking, WALKING ON CLOUDS, type of feeling!
Self adhesive, removable. We recommend keeping them in your shoe and not removing them to keep the adhesive strong.
Reduces extra space in the shoe for those who have narrow feet and want a tighter fit.

Please note, since this cushion is very dense, it is only applicable if you have some extra space. If you have a wide foot and no extra space within the shoe, we do not recommend adding any inserts.

Shipping, Returns & Exchange

Shipping

Orders placed within the United States will ship via USPS. Orders placed outside of the United States will ship via DHL Express. Duties and taxes are included and calculated at checkout. You may select your shipping method at checkout. Transit times and costs will be estimated at checkout.

*Shipping times do NOT include handling time.

Returns & Exchange

We hope the shoe fits! If not, we offer hassle-free Returns and exchanges within the US! Items may be exchanged or returned within 30 days of your order. All items MUST be in original condition to be eligible for a return.

Read the FULL Policy HERE for complete details.

Add some finishing touches

Fairy Dust

Talc-free powder to reduce foot sweat

$23

Heel Good Insert

$15

Suede Insole

$15

5" of pure delusion

Because subtle was never an option.

Faux mink. real drama.

Ultra-soft, fluffy, and unapologetically extra.

3/4" clear platform

Our iconic Olympian silhouette, gone fuzzy.

Only 200 exist

First Edition. Individually numbered. Never reproduced in its original form.

Why you'll love it

Designed for questionable decisions.

An April Fool’s joke you refused to let stay a joke. The Fuzzy Olympian combines our iconic 5" heel and 3/4" platform with ultra-soft faux mink fur and absolutely no regard for practicality.

Faux Mink Fur

Soft, fluffy, and unnecessarily fabulous.

ICONIC OLYMPIAN SILHOUETTE

Our signature 5" heel, with a fuzzy plot twist.

3/4" CLEAR PLATFORM

Because even delusion deserves a solid foundation.

FIRST EDITION COLLECTIBLE

One of only 200 individually numbered pairs.

collectible
100% Vegan
Made by women
all-day Comfort
5" STATEMENT HEEL
ULTRA-SOFT FAUX MINK

A note from our founder

I genuinely never thought...

these would exist. What started as an April Fool’s joke turned into you guys refusing to let me forget about them… so I listened. 😂

We made just 200 pairs. Thank you for always encouraging us to have fun, take the risk, and occasionally make the completely unnecessary. Welcome to the Fuzzyverse. 🤍

xx, Alexa

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best heels for bikini and bodybuilding competitions?

Our Olympian heels are designed specifically for bikini and bodybuilding competitions, offering the perfect balance of stability, height, and clear-shoe aesthetic that judges look for on stage.

What is the difference between Olympian and Naked heels?

Olympian heels are specifically designed and approved for the bodybuilding stage, offering the stability, support, and confidence competitors need to perform at their best. Naked heels take that same comfort-first philosophy and reimagine it for everyday life, with elevated styles designed to keep up with everything from workdays to nights out.

What makes Shoe Fairy different from other clear heels?

Shoe Fairy heels are thoughtfully desinged for comfort, stability, and confidence. From our signature cushioned insoles and supportive construction to premium materials and performance-driven design, every pair is made to help you look and feel your best whether you're on stage or on your feet all day.

Are Shoe Fairy heels comfortable for long wear?

Yes! Every pair features a cushioned insole and soft/flexible plastic to keep you comfortable through full prejudging and finals, even in 4 or 5 inch heights.

Do your heels come in wide width?

Yes!We offer the following widths: Narrow, standard, semi-wide and wide. You can shop by width.

Are 4 inch or 5 inch heels better for competition?

It depends on the federation, your height, and your comfort level. 5 inch heels create a longer leg line and are popular in bikini divisions, while 4 inch heels are easier to walk in and often preferred for figure or first-time competitors.

Do you ship internationally?

Yes — we ship worldwide. Shipping costs and delivery times are calculated at checkout based on your destination.

Still have questions? Contact Us or Start a Chat! Our team has worn them too. We're happy to help.

Shoes

It is a bit tight the upper part of silicone strap so it cuts my blood circulation a bit. Needs improvement. Trying to stretch them so I can wear them for the show

MOST COMFY SHOES EVER

These are hands down the most comfortable high heels I have ever worn in my freaking life. I cannot say enough good things about them!

I was SO skeptical about ordering from The Shoe Fairy because the specific shoes I needed are considered a narrow fit, and I have wider feet. I actually held off on buying them for way too long because I was convinced they wouldn’t work for me. Now I’m mad at myself for waiting!

I followed their sizing recommendations and sized up. I’m typically a 7.5–8 in most shoes, but because of my wider feet, I ordered a size 9. They fit like an absolute glove. I maybe even have a tiny bit of wiggle room, but I would MUCH rather have a little extra room than have my feet crammed into a heel, especially when I’ll be posing and walking in them on show day.

I also ordered the ball-of-foot cushion inserts just in case I needed a little extra comfort or a more secure fit, and honestly, I don’t even think I need them. But I’m glad I have them as an option!

I genuinely cannot get over how freaking comfortable these shoes are. I was expecting competition heels to be something I’d just have to tolerate, and these completely proved me wrong. I cannot WAIT to wear them on show day.

I will absolutely be ordering from The Shoe Fairy again. The quality of these heels completely exceeded my expectations, and based on this experience, I wouldn’t hesitate to try their other products either.
10/10. If you’re hesitating like I was.. BUY THE SHOES 👠✨

Love

Disappointing. Straps too big...previous versions fit great

This isn't my first pair in this size/style, but sadly it's the only one that has oversized straps around the foot. I contacted customer service, exchanged them, and still had the same issue. I didn't want to have to buy ankle straps after years of wearing the same shoe, but it seems it's the only way it'll stay on my foot.

Show day disaster

Bought a pair of the wide mule a few months ago! They were great for practicing, then when I was competing in April both soles came loose and were flopping around. I super glued them back together. Luckily I know how to walk in heels or I would have tripped or rolled an ankle on stage!