Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule
Olympian Mule

Olympian Mule

Regular price $79.99 Sale price $60.00


Scared to rock a mule? Worried your foot will slide right out and it won't feel secure?

You're not alone! We realized this was a common problem so we created the solution! Our Olympian Mule has extended (comfortable) plastic coverage to ensure your foot feels secure. This strapless look is bound to elegonate your legs for a sleek, fabulous look!

Features:  5" heel and 3/4" platform, synthetic sparkly insole (Vegan-Friendly), flexible/soft plastic upper, cushioned insole for amazing comfort, rounded footbed, vegan heels

Sizing: Medium width, true to size. If you are a half size, we suggest sizing DOWN to the nearest whole size. These run more on the "big" side.

If your foot is wider or the plastic feels tight, you may apply heat from a blow dryer for 10-30 seconds to help the plastic expand and stretch. 

Narrow Feet? Check out our custom insert here.

Maintenance: Easy to clean insole! This insole can be wiped clean in just 60 seconds with some warm water and soap. It dries instantly and will look brand new.   



Yes, we accept returns! You may return your items for store credit or a refund within 30 days of your original order. Read the full Policy HERE.


These heels do NOT come in wide styles! However, we do have a few styles that have a wider toe bed. These include Olympian, Lush, Luminous, Bella, Nova Bella and Knockout.


Priority U.S Shipping: 2-3 business days
Express U.S Shipping: 1-2 business days

*Shipping times do NOT include handling time. Orders placed Monday – Thursday are typically shipped within 24hrs or less. Orders placed Friday morning will be shipped on Friday. Orders placed Friday afternoon/evening, Saturday and Sunday will be shipped on Monday.

For international information, click HERE.

We hope the shoe fits! If not, we have hassle-free Returns. You may return your items for store credit or a refund within 30 days of your original order. 

Read the FULL Policy HERE for complete details.


Why choose us?
Women Empowering Women

We are women owned and operated! The Shoe Fairy was founded in 2015 by a fellow competitor! Alexa noticed there was no one known for stage heels and that’s how the idea of the Shoe Fairy was born. This was and is still a dream. A dream that is becoming reality. That’s what sets us apart from other companies. This is not just a business. This is a PASSION that blood, sweat, tears and heart has been poured into. When you shop with the Shoe Fairy, you are supporting people that will support and love you right back. 

We're Here to Help

Let's connect! Customer Service is our number 1 priority. No question is silly to us! We are here to make your shopping experience be the best it can be. Our products are our specialty and we love to answer your questions! When you shop with the Shoe Fairy you are just a click away from getting in contact directly with our team for one on one support.

Customer Reviews

Based on 72 reviews
Comfy but not what I wanted

These shoes are very comfortable and convenient to slip on and off. However, due to there being no strap, it feels a little unstable/unsteady.

I had originally wanted the Olympian (with straps) not the Olympian mule, but they were out of stock.

My new favorite shoe

This is my first year competing and I knew I wanted a shoe with an ankle strap that I could feel secure in while walking on stage. I've watched all kinds of competitors on Youtube talking about the shoes fairy and I finally looked into them when it came time to order. They have some of the most beautiful shoes and I chose the Olympians, the pictures made them look super comfortable and after wearing heals as much as I have I knew comfort was something I wanted. I ordered the Olympians they arrived quickly and in beautiful packaging and they truly are the most comfortable heels I've ever worn and I added the detachable ankle strap for added security while I'm on stage, but I now have a beautiful shoe and I am so excited for the show.

Wow. I’m shocked

This is my second pair of competition heels. First pair was from Amazon. Decided to purchase these because I’ve heard such good reviews. Was very skeptical because I didn’t know what size I would be and I normally wouldn’t buy something from the US (I live in Canada so shipping rates and such are much higher). I was also worried that they wouldn’t fit me properly. I WAS SO WRONG!! Such an amazing shoe. Surprisingly extremely comfortable! Highly recommend!!!

Love this heel

Super comfortable and very easy to get used to walking in heels if you’re a first timer!


Perfect fit. Super comfortable

People who bought this product, also bought